Walgreens downgraded by S&P Global Ratings into speculative-grade

Retail Dive reports that the drugstore retailer faces debt maturities, and analysts said the upending of some strategies introduces new uncertainties.

(July 23, 2024)  Retail Dive reports that S&P Global Ratings analysts have downgraded Walgreens Boot Alliance by two notches to ‘BB’ from ‘BBB—’, which puts the drugstore company into speculative-grade territory.

Analysts Diya Iyer and Hanna Zhang cited guidance for the year “notably below” their expectations. They said, “Material strategic changes, limited cash flow generation, and large maturities in coming years are key risks to the business.”

The company is struggling in its retail business and pharmacy operations, they said in a Friday client note. In the U.S., margins are taking a hit on the pharmacy side due to reimbursement pressure and on the retail side due to declining sales volume and higher shrinkage. They expect Walgreens’ S&P Global Ratings-adjusted EBITDA margin to fall more than 100 basis points this fiscal year, dipping below 5%, from 6% last year, though the company’s cost cuts will counter that somewhat.

Walgreens’ debt and its need to refinance much of it represent another “key risk,” they said. This coming November, Walgreens faces $1.4 billion in maturities, mostly U.S. bonds. Another $2.8 billion comes due in fiscal 2026 and $1.8 billion in fiscal 2027. The analysts called Walgreens’ move to consolidate cash “prudent” in case refinancing isn’t possible.

“We will be monitoring how Walgreens’ new management addresses this large debt load closely amid its persistently weak performance and higher interest rates,” Iyer and Zhang said.

Beyond those financial realities, though, are strategic weaknesses. Ex-Cigna executive Tim Wentworth took over as CEO last fall and has overseen a strategic review this year that has entailed more layoffs and store closures.

Walgreens has also upended some of its plans to expand its medical care operations, divesting or shrinking many of its original investments and plans. Last month, for example, the company announced that it would reduce its stake in value-based medical chain VillageMD, saying it will no longer be the company’s majority owner after closing dozens of the clinics last year. The company first poured $1 billion into VillageMD in 2020 and more than doubled its stake for another $5.2 billion the following year, but the banner’s waning value helped drive a $6 billion loss in Q2.

Despite such moves, Iyer and Zhang said they continue to see the VillageMD banner as “a significant drag on profitability due to the rising cost of labor, pressures from reimbursement, and lower volumes.”

Walgreens’ acquisition streak led S&P analysts to believe it would divest its Boots U.K. business, which could have helped pay down $8 billion to $10 billion in debt. But the company called off the idea about two years ago.

“We believe these frequent and large changes to the company’s strategic plans diminish management’s credibility to execute on a sustainable and cohesive operating model for Walgreens in both the near and long term,” Iyer and Zhang said.

Gains that Walgreens has managed to eke from its medical operations haven’t offset declines in retail, they also said, adding that they are closely watching what it does next with its massive footprint. Last year, the company announced that it would close 150 stores in the U.S. and 300 in the U.K. last month, it said it was reviewing 25% of its current footprint, with plans to shutter a “significant portion” of its roughly 8,700 stores.

“Our ratings continue to reflect Walgreens’ large scale and its efforts to address its credit metric profile. With almost $140 billion in sales in fiscal 2023 and a diverse array of global businesses, Walgreens remains prominent in the drugstore space,” they said. “However, we think its scale is providing less protection to profitability at least partly due to inconsistent strategic direction.”